This place is amazing. Although they don't take reservations, we were able to enjoy drinks and appetizers at one of their bars. The Old Fashioneds here are fantastic. For appetizers, we had Prime Spears, which were delicious—the prime meats paired perfectly with the asparagus. For our main course, we had Prime Ribs and butterflied prawns. The Prime Ribs were a bit too thick for my taste, but the butterflied prawns were incredibly tasty.

Second time going and it’s always a great experience. Food is always amazing. Sunset shrimp appetizer was perfect for summer/the heat. Everything cooked perfectly. Ribeye and prawns were delicious. Was so full I had to take leftovers, but that’s not a bad thing. Many people in my friends circle love it here and we go for special events like our wedding anniversary or a birthday. Thanks for the nice experience. Always love being on mirror lake, having some wine and eating good food.

Didn't have time to wait to eat. We knew to expect a long wait but I thought maybe if we went late in the evening the wait might be shorter. Nope! :) That's OK. We had an old fashioned and walked the beautiful grounds. A fantastic operation. Definitely a destination restaurant deserving of its reputation. Just plan to make a whole afternoon out of it.

Excellent. Excellent. Excellent. The service is great. The overall experience is wonderful. The property is amazing, and the views breath-taking . Not only will you have the best meal of your life, but it will also be a great memory.

The absolute best prime rib I have ever had. House potatoes are incredible. The old fashioneds go without even needing to be talked about. One of my favorite dinning experiences of my 58 plus years!!! We strongly recommend that you make time to stop!

Classic supper club, we love going here! Along with great service and a great atmosphere. You almost always will have an hour to two hour wait but it is well worth it. The new outside bar was a great add. Plenty of beautiful places to wait for you table to be ready and have a few cocktails while you wait. We of course love the old fashioned but the tipsy canoe and pink moccasin are our go tos as well

What can you say, classic Wisconsin Supper Club. Get there early as there are no reservations and there will be a wait, but well worth it. I think Ishnala refers to it as a two Old Fashioned wait. (Brandy Old Fashioned, sweet). Arrived at 3pm on a Saturday and waited about 1hr & 45min. They have 3 bars & and outside bar with beach area, plenty of places to park yourself and enjoy the scenery and experience. Dinner was great, had the Salmon and will return!

Our second visit to Ishnala was exceptional. We arrived earlier and had requested a window seat. The hostess group suggested a “window view”. We enjoyed “Chief Ishnala” drinks while sitting in a covered area (it was raining) off of the Tee Pee bar. When seated, a staff member checked in with us to be certain we were happy with our table. WOW! Customer satisfaction is high priority with this restaurant. Our food was exceptional. Service was outstanding. We will definitely be back! The setting is rustic with pine trees and lake beauty. You can enjoy multiple levels to enjoy drinks or walk outdoors and take in the gorgeous grounds. A Must See and visit while in Wisconsin!

What a beautiful experience. The historical significance of this supper club is amazing. They celebrated 70 years in business last year. Service is first rate.

Pretty unique place. Long wait (minimum of 1 hr) but worth it. Sat at one of their bars while waiting. Had a cocktail & cheese curds. Both were very yummy. Was seated for meal, received rolls, crackers & creamed cheddar cheese. Good stuff. For the entree, I ordered prime rib & fried shrimp with asparagus. Also had a salad with their house dressing. All of it was pretty awesome. Topped it off with chocolate cheesecake (I think). Also very delicious. It was a lot of food so I have another meal for tomorrow. My friend had the carmel crunch cake & said that was great too.